Odds are, yes. Maine is among the nearly twenty states that have sued Standard & Poor's Financial Services, LLC and McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. for alleged unfair trade practices in violation of state law, but that litigation is now in federal court and subject to a motion to transfer pending before the U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, according to the National Law Journal.
Preti Flaherty attorneys Sigmund D. Schutz and Michael S. Smith serve as Maine counsel for Standard & Poors and McGraw-Hill in coordination with Cahill Gordon in New York City.
S&P Credit Rating Litigation in Maine Short-Lived?
Friday, April 12, 2013
U.S. Supreme Court Paves the Way for Securities Class Actions
Friday, March 15, 2013
On February 27, 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision in Amgen, Inc. et al. v. Connecticut Retirement Plans and Trust Funds, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 11-1085 (2013). In Amgen, the Court addressed the issue of whether plaintiffs seeking class certification of a securities fraud claim brought under Rule 10b-5 must prove the materiality of the alleged misstatements and omissions as a predicate to class certification.
In a much-anticipated decision, the U.S. Supreme Court allowed shareholders of Amgen to sue Amgen, as a group, without first having to show that Amgen had materially and fraudulently inflated its stock price.
According to the majority, the early stages of class action litigation are intended to ensure that cases are litigated fairly and efficiently. In the Court’s eyes, to hold otherwise "would have us put the cart before the horse." Moreover, the Court believes this holding does not run afoul of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23 (governing class actions) because the question of materiality is one that is common to all class members.
Of course, while plaintiffs do not have to meet this hurdle at the class certification stage, plaintiffs will need to meet this requirement once the case is evaluated on the merits, either at trial or by summary judgment. With this decision, there is also the likelihood for more motions for summary judgment filed sooner than later following class certification in Rule 10b-5 cases.
In a much-anticipated decision, the U.S. Supreme Court allowed shareholders of Amgen to sue Amgen, as a group, without first having to show that Amgen had materially and fraudulently inflated its stock price.
According to the majority, the early stages of class action litigation are intended to ensure that cases are litigated fairly and efficiently. In the Court’s eyes, to hold otherwise "would have us put the cart before the horse." Moreover, the Court believes this holding does not run afoul of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23 (governing class actions) because the question of materiality is one that is common to all class members.
Of course, while plaintiffs do not have to meet this hurdle at the class certification stage, plaintiffs will need to meet this requirement once the case is evaluated on the merits, either at trial or by summary judgment. With this decision, there is also the likelihood for more motions for summary judgment filed sooner than later following class certification in Rule 10b-5 cases.
Maine Supreme Court Upholds Order Requiring Insurer to Pay Restitution and Civil Penalty Stemming From Deceptive Practices by its Agent
Monday, January 28, 2013
The Maine Superintendent of Insurance (which has oversight over insurance companies and agents that sell insurance and annuity products to the public) found the Bankers Life agent failed to evaluate the suitability of his recommendations, was incompetent, untrustworthy and financially irresponsible in his annuity sales, and made misleading comparisons between the woman’s existing investments and those offered by Bankers Life. The Superintendent ordered Bankers Life to pay restitution and a $100,000 civil penalty stemming from these deceptive practices.
Bankers Life appealed to the Superior Court. The Superior Court affirmed the decision of the Superintendent. Bankers Life appealed to the Maine Supreme Court.
In Bankers Life and Casualty Company v Superintendent of Insurance, 2013 ME 17 (January 10, 2013), the Maine Supreme Court affirmed the Superintendent’s decision, finding the Superintendent did not abuse her discretion in imposing restitution and a civil penalty against Bankers Life.
The Bankers Life decision is significant in at least two respects. First, it seems that the Maine Bureau of Insurance has taken a keen interest in pursuing actions against insurers for unsuitable sales of annuities to the elderly. In all likelihood, this will be an ongoing trend, particularly given Maine's aging populations. Second, the decision highlights the challenge in overturning agency decisions. Under the applicable standard a court will reverse administrative fact findings by a state agency only if the decision "plainly compels a contrary result." That means that focus in defending such matters should be at the administrative level.
New York Times Shines Spotlight on “Mini-Madoffs”
Friday, January 11, 2013
by Michael S. Smith
On January 6, the New York Times ran a story on Philip Horn, a Wells Fargo financial adviser in the Los Angeles area who recently pleaded guilty to defrauding Wells Fargo and more than a dozen of his clients out of at least $732,000.
Horn, described by clients as charismatic and outgoing, “a great guy and a straight shooter,” spent a good deal of his time at the upscale Braemar Country Club. The club was a lucrative source of clients for Horn, as well as the scene of a tense, public confrontation with one of his defrauded investors. It appears that Horn bilked numerous of his fellow club members out of sums rising into the six figures and perhaps beyond.
Though the Horn affair provides the article’s narrative hook, its true focus is on a much bigger issue:
For more information, contact Preti Flaherty Attorney Michael S. Smith or visit Preti's Financial Services Practice Group page to learn more.
On January 6, the New York Times ran a story on Philip Horn, a Wells Fargo financial adviser in the Los Angeles area who recently pleaded guilty to defrauding Wells Fargo and more than a dozen of his clients out of at least $732,000.
Horn, described by clients as charismatic and outgoing, “a great guy and a straight shooter,” spent a good deal of his time at the upscale Braemar Country Club. The club was a lucrative source of clients for Horn, as well as the scene of a tense, public confrontation with one of his defrauded investors. It appears that Horn bilked numerous of his fellow club members out of sums rising into the six figures and perhaps beyond.
Though the Horn affair provides the article’s narrative hook, its true focus is on a much bigger issue:
While Mr. Horn is a relatively minor player in the pantheon of financial fraud, his actions highlight the persistent problems with policing the industry, even after the wave of rules enacted since the collapse of Bernard L. Madoff’s giant Ponzi scheme in 2008 ... Every month, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, a Wall Street watchdog, penalizes more than 100 brokers for various actions, including unauthorized trading and fraudulent activities ….Unfortunately, the Horn case and others like it show that financial fraud is alive and well in the post-Madoff era. The SEC and other federal and state regulators have more than enough large-scale investigations to keep them busy. As a result, relatively small-scale financial advisers like Horn who defraud their clients are often able to slip under the enforcement authorities’ radar for years.
For more information, contact Preti Flaherty Attorney Michael S. Smith or visit Preti's Financial Services Practice Group page to learn more.
Massachusetts Quick to Crack Down on Crowdfunding
Tuesday, January 8, 2013
Crowdfunding, which allows smaller private
companies to sell directly to investors, has recently come under fire in
Massachusetts. Secretary of State William Galvin has filed fraud charges
against two out-of-state oil and gas operations relative to their sale of
unregistered securities to investors in Massachusetts.
In
the first instance, Prodigy Oil and Gas LLC allegedly employed a cold-caller
who had been found gulty of theft. Prodigy sold at least $464,000 in unregistered
securities to one Massachusetts investor. In the second case, Synergy Oil LLC
of Oklahoma allegedly sold $35,000 of unregistered securities to two investors.
Through the JOBS Act, signed into law April 5, 2012, small business and entrepreneurs will be able to sell equity (up to $1,000,000 annually) directly to investors to finance their business venture. Crowdfunding is technically not legal yet. Once it is allowed, it must occur on SEC- registered websites. The SEC has until 2014 to adopt rules relative to crowdfunding.
Would-be investors should heed the warning that Crowdfunding is not yet legal or regulated. Proceed at your peril.
Top Investor Threats of 2012
Thursday, January 3, 2013
What were the top investor threats of 2012? According to a speaker during the NASAA roundtable session at the November, 2012 annual meeting of the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association, the top four new threats were:
- Crowd funding / internet securities offerings
- Inappropriate advice or practices by investment advisors
- Scams involving self-directed IRAs to mask fraud
- EB-5 investment for visa scams
The top six persistent threats were:
- Gold / precious metals
- Risky oil / gas drilling schemes
- Promissory notes
- Real estate investment schemes
- Reg. D / Rule 506 private offerings
- Unlicensed salespersons giving liquidation recommendations (for example, recommendations to sell stocks to buy a variable annuity by an insurance agent not licensed as an investment advisor or stockbroker)
FINRA Issues Guidance on Suitability Rule Concerning Definition of "Customer" and "Investment Strategy"
Thursday, December 27, 2012
Regulatory Notice 12-55, Guidance on FINRA's Suitability Rule
Davis Polk. Guidance on FINRA's Suitability Rule
FINRA Clarifies Customer and Investment Strategy Terms Under the Suitability Rule
FINRA Suitability Overview
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
